I've got admits for both of these schools and need to make a decision. I'm working in supply chain.
I'm torn because there's some conflicting information concerning the rankings. Broad is ranked better by both Financial Times and Businessweek, that much is clear.
However, the information on Businessweek says that Smeal grads have average salaries of around $101,000, which is about $10,000 more than Broad grads. I'm all about the bottom line so in this sense I am leaning towards Broad.
Surveying LinkedIn for graduate information doesn't provide any clear results, but they both seem to do well for supply chain so that seems like a wash to me.
What should I do?
Big decision: Broad or Smeal
Posted Feb 11, 2015 16:15
I'm torn because there's some conflicting information concerning the rankings. Broad is ranked better by both Financial Times and Businessweek, that much is clear.
However, the information on Businessweek says that Smeal grads have average salaries of around $101,000, which is about $10,000 more than Broad grads. I'm all about the bottom line so in this sense I am leaning towards Broad.
Surveying LinkedIn for graduate information doesn't provide any clear results, but they both seem to do well for supply chain so that seems like a wash to me.
What should I do?
Posted Feb 11, 2015 19:58
I think you mean that Smeal folk earn much LESS than Broad grads. Salary differences often reflect taxes and other cost of living differences in those states more than quality. In this case, however, Broad is the better school on almost every variable in the FT ranking.
Posted Feb 16, 2015 14:19
That's what's baffling: according to Businessweek, Smeal grads make about $101,000, whereas Broad grads make $91,000:
http://www.bloomberg.com/bschools/rankings/full_time_mba_profiles/pennstate.html
http://www.bloomberg.com/bschools/rankings/full_time_mba_profiles/michstate.html
Not sure what to make of this, as it is conflicting with most other factors.
http://www.bloomberg.com/bschools/rankings/full_time_mba_profiles/pennstate.html
http://www.bloomberg.com/bschools/rankings/full_time_mba_profiles/michstate.html
Not sure what to make of this, as it is conflicting with most other factors.
Posted Feb 16, 2015 14:44
That could be PPP differences, or different years?
Posted Feb 18, 2015 09:46
Looking at the current career reports at least, a larger percentage of Smeal grads from that class went into consulting roles (27 percent vs. 6 percent...); and since consulting careers pay more in general, this is probably what's inflating the Smeal salaries.
Posted Feb 24, 2015 16:39
I've decided to go with Broad. Thanks for the assist!
Related Business Schools
Other Related Content
MBA Programs in Supply Chain Management: Beyond Logistics
Article Feb 05, 2013
How sustainability and other current topics are making supply chain roles exciting
Top Business Schools for Supply Chain Management
Top List
Effective supply chain management (SCM) practices have become essential to firms in many industries, particularly since globalization has widened the geographic distances between suppliers, manufacturers, and customers
Hot Discussions
-
Dilemma over IE business school EMBA
Apr 05, 2024 274 12 -
Oxford executive diplomas
Apr 01, 2024 258 9 -
Cambridge Judge vs RSM
Apr 09, 2024 256 7 -
How to evaluate IIFT's Executive PGDM
Apr 03, 2024 144 5 -
Any guesses as to why several schools are reporting big increases in applications?
Mar 30, 2024 224 3 -
Take GMAT again?
Apr 23 02:15 AM 70 3 -
MBA at Imperial vs Bayes vs Warwick for international student
Mar 25, 2024 188 1 -
General MBA for experienced technologist
Apr 17 03:54 PM 103 1