Just saw that US News has preview the top 10 schools for its 2019 ranking. This list is unordered:
Columbia
Dartmouth Tuck
Harvard
MIT Sloan
Northwestern Kellogg
Stanford
UC Berkeley - Haas
Chicago - Booth
Michigan - Ross
Wharton
What this means is Yale SOM has left the top 10 and Ross has entered it. Ross has been showing some good placement stats ($146k average for 2017 MBA grads), with many going into consulting and tech (Amazon likes Ross grads...)
US News MBA Ranking 2019 - Top 10 Preview
Posted Mar 13, 2018 16:47
Columbia
Dartmouth Tuck
Harvard
MIT Sloan
Northwestern Kellogg
Stanford
UC Berkeley - Haas
Chicago - Booth
Michigan - Ross
Wharton
What this means is Yale SOM has left the top 10 and Ross has entered it. Ross has been showing some good placement stats ($146k average for 2017 MBA grads), with many going into consulting and tech (Amazon likes Ross grads...)
Posted Mar 14, 2018 18:06
zzzz... boring...
Posted Mar 19, 2018 18:19
I guess Yale leaving the top 10 is notable. Of course, Yale is still ranked higher than Ross in the FT.
Posted Mar 20, 2018 19:23
Here's the ordered top 10 list:
Tied for 1. Harvard
Tied for 1. Booth
3. Wharton
4. Stanford
5. MIT - Sloan
6. Northwestern - Kellogg
Tied for 7. Haas
Tied for 7. Michigan - Ross
9. Columbia
10. Dartmouth - Tuck
It looks like they have updated their methodology to discount GMAT scores if a school didn't submit the scores for at least 50 percent of a class:
This year for the first time, MBA programs that reported that less than 50 percent of their full-time fall 2017 entering students submitted average GMAT scores and average GRE quantitative and verbal scores received less credit for those test scores in the rankings.
Specifically, their weighted percentile distributions were adjusted downward by the proportion of the percentage of the student body that submitted test scores in relation to the 50 percent threshold. For example, if 25 percent of the entering class submitted test scores, then the test scores were reduced in value in the ranking model by 50 percent. For the purposes of determining the proportion of full-time fall 2017 entering students with scores, the percentage submitting GMAT and GRE were totaled.
Tied for 1. Harvard
Tied for 1. Booth
3. Wharton
4. Stanford
5. MIT - Sloan
6. Northwestern - Kellogg
Tied for 7. Haas
Tied for 7. Michigan - Ross
9. Columbia
10. Dartmouth - Tuck
It looks like they have updated their methodology to discount GMAT scores if a school didn't submit the scores for at least 50 percent of a class:
[quote]This year for the first time, MBA programs that reported that less than 50 percent of their full-time fall 2017 entering students submitted average GMAT scores and average GRE quantitative and verbal scores received less credit for those test scores in the rankings.
Specifically, their weighted percentile distributions were adjusted downward by the proportion of the percentage of the student body that submitted test scores in relation to the 50 percent threshold. For example, if 25 percent of the entering class submitted test scores, then the test scores were reduced in value in the ranking model by 50 percent. For the purposes of determining the proportion of full-time fall 2017 entering students with scores, the percentage submitting GMAT and GRE were totaled.[/quote]
Posted Apr 09, 2018 18:25
Texas Christain University (Neeley) has been removed from the US News Ranking:
https://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/college-rankings-blog/articles/2018-04-04/update-to-texas-christian-universitys-mba-ranking
They overstated their average GMAT. Said it was 678 when it was actually 640.
A bit similar to what happened to Temple in the Online MBA Ranking:
https://find-mba.com/board/distance-learning/temple-foxs-online-mba-removed-from-us-news-ranking-52451
https://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/college-rankings-blog/articles/2018-04-04/update-to-texas-christian-universitys-mba-ranking
They overstated their average GMAT. Said it was 678 when it was actually 640.
A bit similar to what happened to Temple in the Online MBA Ranking:
https://find-mba.com/board/distance-learning/temple-foxs-online-mba-removed-from-us-news-ranking-52451
Posted Apr 10, 2018 15:52
Texas Christain University (Neeley) has been removed from the US News Ranking:
https://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/college-rankings-blog/articles/2018-04-04/update-to-texas-christian-universitys-mba-ranking
They overstated their average GMAT. Said it was 678 when it was actually 640.
A bit similar to what happened to Temple in the Online MBA Ranking:
https://find-mba.com/board/distance-learning/temple-foxs-online-mba-removed-from-us-news-ranking-52451
Simple oversight, or something more sinister?
https://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/college-rankings-blog/articles/2018-04-04/update-to-texas-christian-universitys-mba-ranking
They overstated their average GMAT. Said it was 678 when it was actually 640.
A bit similar to what happened to Temple in the Online MBA Ranking:
https://find-mba.com/board/distance-learning/temple-foxs-online-mba-removed-from-us-news-ranking-52451
[/quote]
Simple oversight, or something more sinister?
Posted May 08, 2018 21:30
From an article I read, they attributed it to human error - whoever filled in the info put the wrong value in the field. They normally have internal processes for checking these things, but for whatever reason they didn't catch it. Was it something as simple as confusing the mean and median values maybe?
Posted May 09, 2018 21:31
Yes, maybe something like that. If they can make a mistake like that, and since this has happened before with another US News ranking, it sort of undermines the credibility of the publication, at least a little.
Related Business Schools
Other Related Content
LinkedIn Launches MBA Rankings of US Business Schools
News Jan 11, 2024
MBA Rankings: Finding the Best Business Schools
Article Jul 24, 2012
From the FT to Businessweek, we discuss the importance of rankings and how they work
Hot Discussions
-
MBA Strathclyde vs Aston vs NTU
Apr 17, 2024 615 13 -
Cambridge Judge vs RSM
Apr 09, 2024 271 7 -
How to evaluate IIFT's Executive PGDM
Apr 03, 2024 148 5 -
Any guesses as to why several schools are reporting big increases in applications?
Mar 30, 2024 235 3 -
Take GMAT again?
Apr 23 02:15 AM 94 3 -
Is Wharton actually better than Harvard at the moment?
15 hours ago 33 2 -
City or Manchester for MiF?
Apr 09, 2024 144 1 -
Two MBAs for the price of one
Apr 12, 2024 205 1