Master in Management Programs Versus MBAs

Want to study business, but don't have work experience? An MSc or MiM might be right for you

If you're researching MBA programs, you might have come across other master's degrees in business. An increasing number of business schools are offering Master of Science in Management (MSc) or Masters in Management (MiM) programs alongside traditional MBAs. These “M-something” programs are generally around a year to a year and a half long, and cover similar topics as MBA programs.

Because they seem similar to MBAs, many potential applicants see MSc and MiM degrees as alternatives to MBA programs, but this is not necessarily the case. According to Paul Baines, the director of the 13-month MSc in Management program at Cranfield University's School of Management, the audiences of Cranfield's MBA and MSc programs “are more or less mutually exclusive.”

“If you've got more than three years of work experience, you'll be recommended onto the MBA" (rather than an MSc), says Baines.

Aimed at students with little to no work experience, the curriculums for MSc and MiM programs tend to vary from that of an MBA. Many focus on core business subjects, and lack the range of electives that an MBA would offer. For example, while the MBA program at the University of St. Gallen offers almost 30 electives in 5 functional areas, students in the school's Master of Arts in Strategy & International Management (SIM) program can choose from fewer than 10 electives.

Likewise, students in the 10-month Master of Management Studies (MMS): Foundations of Business program at Duke University's Fuqua School of Business study many of the same core topic areas as those in the Fuqua MBA program, but lack the ability to focus on specialized areas.

“There are no electives, there's no opportunity for a student to concentrate,” says Kathie Amato, the dean of the MMS program, “so a lot of the opportunity to do a deeper dive, that an MBA would have, does not exist in this program.”

According to Amato, this focus on the core areas of business meets the needs of the program's audience – specifically, those who want to adapt an undergraduate education in liberal arts or science to a career in business.

“We get people who were undergraduate English majors, history majors, or students from engineering and the sciences,” says Amato. “It really runs the gamut.”

Got experience? Want to start a business?

In some cases, students who do have some work experience may also benefit from an MSc or an MiM, particularly if it offers a concentration. For instance, even though the majority of students in the flexible MSc program at HEC Montréal have no work experience, the ones that do find value in gaining deeper insight into their chosen field through a specialization, such as organizational development or business analytics.

“In some of these fields,” says MSc program director Claude Laurin, “there are some candidates that have been working for three or four years, who come back to get more specialized knowledge about their field.”

Cranfield's Paul Baines says that students whose goal is to start their own businesses can benefit from an MSc or an MiM as well, since these programs offer wide, contextual perspective of how business works.

“Somebody wanting to develop their own business with a limited amount of experience would really benefit from doing the MiM because it will give them insight across all the different areas,” Baines says.

Baines also notes another value: for students who want to channel their financial resources into starting a business, an MSc program is usually much less expensive than an MBA.

For entrepreneurial-minded students, some business schools also offer MSc programs specifically designed around the process of business creation. For example, Rotterdam School of Management (RSM) offers an MSc in Entrepreneurship and New Business Venturing, and the Ross School of Business at the University of Michigan offers a Master of Entrepreneurship program through a partnership with the university's College of Engineering.

Learning by doing

As many of these MScs and other business-focused master's programs cater to students with no work experience, some provide opportunities for students to get hands-on experience through projects or internship components. Students in Duke's MMS program, for example, can opt to do two internships: one before the program starts and one during the long winter break.

“For the students who believe that their lack of work experience may be a significant issue,they tend to take advantage of those opportunities,” says Kathie Amato. “And companies value that.”

Likewise, students in HEC Montréal's MSc program can choose between writing a thesis and doing a supervised, hands-on project. According to Claude Laurin, the research component can prepare students to continue on in academia.

“Although we have a lot of our students who are hired by large firms,” he says, “some of them go to the next level, and do a PhD program.”

Post-MSc careers

According to Paul Baines, Cranfield's MSc program is aimed at landing graduates in entry-level business careers, or in graduate training programs in large multinational companies, where they can learn the ropes and figure out what managerial track is right for them. As such, the career services support tends to differ from that offered to MBA students.

“Often, somebody who's doing an MBA is looking to change their career,” says Baines, “so there's a much greater degree of career counseling for career change than there would be on a MiM program.”

Baines notes that Cranfield's MSc career counseling focuses more on job-finding basics like interviewing skills and CV preparation.

Graduates of Duke Fuqua's MMS program are generally interested in finding a business career where they can leverage their undergraduate education and passions.

“Some students have been interested in entertainment, or sports management,” says Kathie Amato. “They end up working for talent agencies, and some work for firms that do sports management.”

“It's a very broad base of opportunities that the students have.”

Photo: sacks08 / Creative Commons

Comments


Related Business Schools

Stanford, California 93 Followers 169 Discussions
Madrid, Spain 2 Followers 39 Discussions
Torino, Italy 6 Followers 42 Discussions
London, United Kingdom 104 Followers 329 Discussions
Ahmedabad, India 11 Followers 76 Discussions
Rotterdam, Netherlands 78 Followers 223 Discussions
St. Gallen, Switzerland 42 Followers 140 Discussions
London, United Kingdom 12 Followers 114 Discussions
Full Profile
Ecully, France 54 Followers 135 Discussions
Full Profile
Cergy-Pontoise, France 41 Followers 180 Discussions
Grenoble Cedex 01, France 26 Followers 117 Discussions
Stockholm, Sweden 23 Followers 25 Discussions
Mont Saint Aignan, France 8 Followers 9 Discussions
Paris cedex 11, France 9 Followers 76 Discussions
Berlin, Germany 13 Followers 100 Discussions
Mannheim, Germany 78 Followers 216 Discussions
London, United Kingdom 58 Followers 405 Discussions
Montréal, Canada 47 Followers 56 Discussions
Lausanne, Switzerland 4 Followers 26 Discussions
Durham, North Carolina 52 Followers 101 Discussions
Ann Arbor, Michigan 39 Followers 87 Discussions
Nice, France 29 Followers 147 Discussions
Madrid, Spain 113 Followers 353 Discussions
Full Profile
Jouy-en-Josas, France 96 Followers 377 Discussions
Bedford, United Kingdom 41 Followers 396 Discussions
London, Canada 38 Followers 77 Discussions
Leipzig, Germany 68 Followers 189 Discussions
London, United Kingdom 7 Followers 63 Discussions

MBA News

Sep 27, 2022

e-Fellows to Host Two In-Person Sessions in Germany with Top Business Schools

Sep 27, 2022

More MBA News

More MBA Articles

Germany is a Rising Force in Business Education

Nov 21, 2022

After a slow start, Germany’s MBA schools are thriving and aiming to compete on the world stage

The MBA Job Market is Robust, Despite Economic Headwinds

Nov 03, 2022

Even as the threat of recession increases, job-seeking MBA graduates still have the upper hand in a tight labor market

Why the Part-time MBA has a Bright Future

Oct 18, 2022

Often undervalued, these flexible degrees are gaining in appeal as the job market tightens

More Articles

Related Top 10 Lists

More Top 10 Lists