US MBA and UK MBA difference


Hello,

Recently I have been reading the posts in this forum and have done some research about MBA program.

Background: 8 years of Engineer in Automotive industry in Sweden with 2 years of team leader role.

I have selected the following programs to consider:
1. Manchester Global MBA program
2. Manchester and Kelley Joint MBA program
3. Illinois iMBA program (Pending now due to need language test)

Currently I am applying for Manchester Global MBA program and consult a MBA student in Manchester and Kelley Joint MBA program. And she prefer Kelley MBA way of teaching more due to that the class is more focus on the actual business case studying and more interaction during the class with classmates and professors. And she feels it is more beneficial than Manchester course. Manchester course has a lot of reading books after the class and writing papers which requires massive of time and energy which is difficult for the full time employee with family.

What do you have any experience between US MBA and UK MBA in terms of way of education?

Personally, I have the family and reading a lot of book and writing papers for each course in Manchester MBA program is a big concern for me.

Thanks for any comment!
Hello,

Recently I have been reading the posts in this forum and have done some research about MBA program.

Background: 8 years of Engineer in Automotive industry in Sweden with 2 years of team leader role.

I have selected the following programs to consider:
1. Manchester Global MBA program
2. Manchester and Kelley Joint MBA program
3. Illinois iMBA program (Pending now due to need language test)

Currently I am applying for Manchester Global MBA program and consult a MBA student in Manchester and Kelley Joint MBA program. And she prefer Kelley MBA way of teaching more due to that the class is more focus on the actual business case studying and more interaction during the class with classmates and professors. And she feels it is more beneficial than Manchester course. Manchester course has a lot of reading books after the class and writing papers which requires massive of time and energy which is difficult for the full time employee with family.

What do you have any experience between US MBA and UK MBA in terms of way of education?

Personally, I have the family and reading a lot of book and writing papers for each course in Manchester MBA program is a big concern for me.

Thanks for any comment!
quote
Duncan
I don;t think there will be a big difference. Alliance MBS is a world-class, US-accredited business school. The difference will be in the students.
I don;t think there will be a big difference. Alliance MBS is a world-class, US-accredited business school. The difference will be in the students.
quote
Thanks for reply.

Quote from alumni of Kelley-Manchester joint mba:
Manchester and Kelley are from different education systems. Manchester will let students to explore and the professors tend to be very hands-off. Kelley is very rigid and the materials, cases used are world-class, and the professors are very dedicated to guide and support the students. Also, both schools provide distant teaching and Kelley's is far more advanced, while Manchester's is like last century. That said, Manchester has its strength in finance.

It is obviously just from one’s perspective and does not necessarily describe the whole difference. However it confuses me more regarding Manchester global mba.
Thanks for reply.

Quote from alumni of Kelley-Manchester joint mba:
Manchester and Kelley are from different education systems. Manchester will let students to explore and the professors tend to be very hands-off. Kelley is very rigid and the materials, cases used are world-class, and the professors are very dedicated to guide and support the students. Also, both schools provide distant teaching and Kelley's is far more advanced, while Manchester's is like last century. That said, Manchester has its strength in finance.

It is obviously just from one’s perspective and does not necessarily describe the whole difference. However it confuses me more regarding Manchester global mba.
quote
Duncan
Fascinating!
Fascinating!
quote
Fascinating!


Which part?
[quote]Fascinating![/quote]

Which part?
quote
Duncan
The whole experience...
The whole experience...
quote
The whole experience...


It would be cool to join this dual mba degree program.

I am concerned about Manchester course which requires a lot of reading and essay writing.
[quote]The whole experience...[/quote]

It would be cool to join this dual mba degree program.

I am concerned about Manchester course which requires a lot of reading and essay writing.
quote
mba hipste...
Hate to break it to, but most MBA programs will require a lot of reading and writing.
Hate to break it to, but most MBA programs will require a lot of reading and writing.
quote
Duncan
I heard that rumour too.
I heard that rumour too.
quote
Hate to break it to, but most MBA programs will require a lot of reading and writing.


OK, the case studying in UK is normally not up-to-date.
[quote]Hate to break it to, but most MBA programs will require a lot of reading and writing.[/quote]

OK, the case studying in UK is normally not up-to-date.
quote
Duncan
Honestly, there is very little difference between new and old cases, other than cost. Okay... I can spend $5000 so my class can have brand new Harvard cases, or I can have lower fees, hire more TAs, put more time into giving better student feedback. Does it really matter, for most topics, if I use a ten year old case in a text book? I am teaching students general management tools with a lifetime's value, not giving them a survey on the recent business problems of the 50 companies that hire the most from Harvard and Ivey business schools.

[Edited by Duncan on Mar 13, 2019]

Honestly, there is very little difference between new and old cases, other than cost. Okay... I can spend $5000 so my class can have brand new Harvard cases, or I can have lower fees, hire more TAs, put more time into giving better student feedback. Does it really matter, for most topics, if I use a ten year old case in a text book? I am teaching students general management tools with a lifetime's value, not giving them a survey on the recent business problems of the 50 companies that hire the most from Harvard and Ivey business schools.
quote
Duncan
Something else: as you get more senior you have to assemble arguments more, assess conflicting sources and demand more data. Scholarly skills help managers do better. Case studies are great for putting the spotlight one a few major issues, and of course students love them. However, case studies don't teach scholarship easily.
Something else: as you get more senior you have to assemble arguments more, assess conflicting sources and demand more data. Scholarly skills help managers do better. Case studies are great for putting the spotlight one a few major issues, and of course students love them. However, case studies don't teach scholarship easily.
quote
Honestly, there is very little difference between new and old cases, other than cost. Okay... I can spend $5000 so my class can have brand new Harvard cases, or I can have lower fees, hire more TAs, put more time into giving better student feedback. Does it really matter, for most topics, if I use a ten year old case in a text book? I am teaching students general management tools with a lifetime's value, not giving them a survey on the recent business problems of the 50 companies that hire the most from Harvard and Ivey business schools.


I appreciate your sharing here!
It is really glad to hear what you said so. I respect and value your opinions.
I can understand your point here. Since I have little knowledge about MBA education, it is beneficial to know about all your experience and lessons.
[quote]Honestly, there is very little difference between new and old cases, other than cost. Okay... I can spend $5000 so my class can have brand new Harvard cases, or I can have lower fees, hire more TAs, put more time into giving better student feedback. Does it really matter, for most topics, if I use a ten year old case in a text book? I am teaching students general management tools with a lifetime's value, not giving them a survey on the recent business problems of the 50 companies that hire the most from Harvard and Ivey business schools. [/quote]

I appreciate your sharing here!
It is really glad to hear what you said so. I respect and value your opinions.
I can understand your point here. Since I have little knowledge about MBA education, it is beneficial to know about all your experience and lessons.

quote

Reply to Post

Related Business Schools

Manchester, United Kingdom 53 Followers 448 Discussions
Bloomington, Indiana 36 Followers 102 Discussions
Online 0 Followers 13 Discussions
Champaign, Illinois 25 Followers 49 Discussions

Related Articles

As MBA Applications Fall, Online and Specialized Master’s Courses Are Booming

Feb 04, 2019

Once considered second-rate, interest in these programs is growing rapidly among cost-conscious and time-starved professionals. Meantime, some full-time two-year MBAs are closing. Are they still viable?

More Articles

Hot Discussions