How to Choose? Help appreciated!!


Hello Everyone!

I want to make some decisions ahead of time and I will much appreciate some help.

I am from Colombia, with 2 years of experience as an entrepreneur and will be joining an MBA in sept 2019.
Although I will eventually return to my venture and family business. I want to have some experience in a Finance related area (2-3 years). So, the Finance track of the program should be considered.

Rotman: Admitted
Pros:
• Canada offers a 3-year work permit.
• Rotman is arguably the best BS in Canada, plus top in Finance.
• Active recruitment from Canadian firms
Cons:
• Employment reports not so great (only 85% after 3 months)
• Salary is lower (low ROI)
• Canada market prefers experience (?)

IESE: Interviewed
Pros:
• Highly ranked globally + affinity with case method
• I love Barcelona and school fit
• 94% of Placement after 3 months and high salaries
Cons:
• Europe's difficulties for immigrants (sponsorship Visa) / just around 36% of graduates manage to get the work permit.
• Spanish (is my native language so I would prefer an English environment)
• More into industry and consulting

LBS: Submitted
Pros:
• London-financial hub
• High reputation+ strong in finance
• 94% of Placement and high salaries
Cons:
• Only 6 months to secure a job + sponsorship from a company
• Brexit? Could it affect the experience?
• Life in Pounds is the most expensive.

Simon Rochester: Interviewed
Pros:
• Strength in Finance
• 93% placement+ high side salary.
• STEM option- 2 years to work in the US
Cons:
• Rochester is isolated + difficulties with recruitment
• Overall not that prestigious-second tier school in a country with over 300 BS.
• US H1B thing+ only around 5% of sponsorships is done in finance area.

Yale, Cornell, Booth: Submitted---(Top choices)
Pros:
• Global reputation
• high placement+ high salary.
Cons:
• 1 year to stay in the US +H1B


Overall, I would need to early decide among Rotman, IESE, and Rochester Simon (before the deposit due date of Rotman).

If afterwards i'm somehow admitted to any of (LBS, Yale, Cornell, Booth) I would need to decide if I assume the lost of the deposit and attend to one of those schools.

Hello Everyone!

I want to make some decisions ahead of time and I will much appreciate some help.

I am from Colombia, with 2 years of experience as an entrepreneur and will be joining an MBA in sept 2019.
Although I will eventually return to my venture and family business. I want to have some experience in a Finance related area (2-3 years). So, the Finance track of the program should be considered.

Rotman: Admitted
Pros:
• Canada offers a 3-year work permit.
• Rotman is arguably the best BS in Canada, plus top in Finance.
• Active recruitment from Canadian firms
Cons:
• Employment reports not so great (only 85% after 3 months)
• Salary is lower (low ROI)
• Canada market prefers experience (?)

IESE: Interviewed
Pros:
• Highly ranked globally + affinity with case method
• I love Barcelona and school fit
• 94% of Placement after 3 months and high salaries
Cons:
• Europe's difficulties for immigrants (sponsorship Visa) / just around 36% of graduates manage to get the work permit.
• Spanish (is my native language so I would prefer an English environment)
• More into industry and consulting

LBS: Submitted
Pros:
• London-financial hub
• High reputation+ strong in finance
• 94% of Placement and high salaries
Cons:
• Only 6 months to secure a job + sponsorship from a company
• Brexit? Could it affect the experience?
• Life in Pounds is the most expensive.

Simon Rochester: Interviewed
Pros:
• Strength in Finance
• 93% placement+ high side salary.
• STEM option- 2 years to work in the US
Cons:
• Rochester is isolated + difficulties with recruitment
• Overall not that prestigious-second tier school in a country with over 300 BS.
• US H1B thing+ only around 5% of sponsorships is done in finance area.

Yale, Cornell, Booth: Submitted---(Top choices)
Pros:
• Global reputation
• high placement+ high salary.
Cons:
• 1 year to stay in the US +H1B


Overall, I would need to early decide among Rotman, IESE, and Rochester Simon (before the deposit due date of Rotman).

If afterwards i'm somehow admitted to any of (LBS, Yale, Cornell, Booth) I would need to decide if I assume the lost of the deposit and attend to one of those schools.
quote
Duncan

The non-Stem US options don't meet your desire to work in for 2/3 years experience. With LBS, I think you would be much more successful.

The non-Stem US options don't meet your desire to work in for 2/3 years experience. With LBS, I think you would be much more successful.
quote
Inactive User

Luckily you are in a position where you can't make a wrong decision. If you get into LBS or Ivy league schools then go for it. I think Rotman is a far better option than Simon. IESE can be interesting too given your fluency with Spanish it may turn out to be a better option as well.

My preference would be LBS > Ivy (Chicago > Cornell > Yale) > IESE > Rotman.
Chuck Simon. Also ROI depends on how much you invest in. Did you get any scholarship at Rotman?

Luckily you are in a position where you can't make a wrong decision. If you get into LBS or Ivy league schools then go for it. I think Rotman is a far better option than Simon. IESE can be interesting too given your fluency with Spanish it may turn out to be a better option as well.

My preference would be LBS > Ivy (Chicago > Cornell > Yale) > IESE > Rotman.
Chuck Simon. Also ROI depends on how much you invest in. Did you get any scholarship at Rotman?
quote

My standings are quite similar:
LBS = Chicago > = Yale > Cornell > IESE >= Rotman.

I got a 20k scholarship at Rotman.

my most immediate concern is deciding between IESE and Rotman. I like both equally, IESE is better ranked but working in Europe is very difficult for a latin-american. Rotman place a lower percentage, but I'd get a 3 year work permit.

I will have to make a decision between Rotman and IESE. afterwards i'll decide if I lost the deposit for (LBS, Chicago, Yale, Cornell).

I mostly agree about rochester Simon, but they actually place better than Rotman.

My standings are quite similar:
LBS = Chicago > = Yale > Cornell > IESE >= Rotman.

I got a 20k scholarship at Rotman.

my most immediate concern is deciding between IESE and Rotman. I like both equally, IESE is better ranked but working in Europe is very difficult for a latin-american. Rotman place a lower percentage, but I'd get a 3 year work permit.

I will have to make a decision between Rotman and IESE. afterwards i'll decide if I lost the deposit for (LBS, Chicago, Yale, Cornell).

I mostly agree about rochester Simon, but they actually place better than Rotman.
quote
Inactive User

Those standings is how I would see them as well. Landing a job in Spain as a Latin American with an MBA from IESE shouldn't be *too* difficult. Canada is a bit 'safer' but with the IESE degree you'd have much stronger lifelong earnings. Also depends on where you want to end up - it will be much harder to transition to Canada after a degree from IESE than one from Rotman.

Those standings is how I would see them as well. Landing a job in Spain as a Latin American with an MBA from IESE shouldn't be *too* difficult. Canada is a bit 'safer' but with the IESE degree you'd have much stronger lifelong earnings. Also depends on where you want to end up - it will be much harder to transition to Canada after a degree from IESE than one from Rotman.
quote

Reply to Post

Related Business Schools

Toronto, Canada 77 Followers 115 Discussions
Barcelona, Spain 29 Followers 169 Discussions
Madrid, Spain 3 Followers 107 Discussions
London, United Kingdom 168 Followers 475 Discussions
Rochester, New York 29 Followers 42 Discussions
New Haven, Connecticut 42 Followers 62 Discussions
Ithaca, New York 89 Followers 136 Discussions
Chicago, Illinois 42 Followers 149 Discussions

Other Related Content

Oct 12, 2023

Calling All German MBA Hopefuls: Join the e-fellows MBA Days in Frankfurt and Hamburg

News Oct 12, 2023

MBA Programs for STEM Professionals: On the Rise

Article Apr 26, 2018

Not only do the courses address a skills gap but give graduates a 36-month US work visa

Hot Discussions