Business Schools in Africa


ralph

There's some good commentary in a recent edition of the Financial Times about Africa needing a new model for business education put forth by Walter Baets, the director of the University of Cape Town Graduate School of Business, South Africa.

Basically, he says that right now, Africa is experiencing "another wave of colonization," where western business schools are setting up shop on the continent. Baets is skeptical:

"Almost without exception, these incoming schools talk about bringing pre-existing European/US models to Africa as if this will be the answer to all of the continent?s problems. None, it seems, has paused to consider whether Africa really will benefit from what they are offering, or if they are missing an opportunity to create something better."


He goes on to note that CEIBS "the Harvard of Africa," Duke and Henley are all setting up campuses, based on the western business school model - neglecting the needs of local students and business.

I tend to agree with Baets' premise - that Africa does need something else. However, might not this sequence be the best situation for Africa right now? Seems to me it would be beneficial to have global brand names like Duke coming in to help pave the way for other models. Isn't that what's happening in the Gulf right now? Top schools have been coming in for the past decade, and now specializations in Islamic finance are starting to develop. I think this kind of local adaptation is key to developing new models.

Thoughts?

There's some good commentary in a recent edition of the Financial Times about Africa needing a new model for business education put forth by Walter Baets, the director of the University of Cape Town Graduate School of Business, South Africa.

Basically, he says that right now, Africa is experiencing "another wave of colonization," where western business schools are setting up shop on the continent. Baets is skeptical:

<blockquote>"Almost without exception, these incoming schools talk about bringing pre-existing European/US models to Africa as if this will be the answer to all of the continent?s problems. None, it seems, has paused to consider whether Africa really will benefit from what they are offering, or if they are missing an opportunity to create something better."</blockquote>

He goes on to note that CEIBS "the Harvard of Africa," Duke and Henley are all setting up campuses, based on the western business school model - neglecting the needs of local students and business.

I tend to agree with Baets' premise - that Africa does need something else. However, might not this sequence be the best situation for Africa right now? Seems to me it would be beneficial to have global brand names like Duke coming in to help pave the way for other models. Isn't that what's happening in the Gulf right now? Top schools have been coming in for the past decade, and now specializations in Islamic finance are starting to develop. I think this kind of local adaptation is key to developing new models.

Thoughts?
quote
Evan2007

Baets is short on specifics, so it sounds to me more like a rant that business schools are moving in UCT's turf without the requisite local knowledge.

Are there any interesting home-grown, alternative models to point to as an example? We aren't given any.

And to his remark that there are "are plenty of good ranked and accredited business schools in Africa." Actually, there are 6, if we're talking about EQUIS, Association of MBAs and AACSB - the ones that matter internationally. Is that "plenty" for Africa's billion + people?

Baets is short on specifics, so it sounds to me more like a rant that business schools are moving in UCT's turf without the requisite local knowledge.

Are there any interesting home-grown, alternative models to point to as an example? We aren't given any.

And to his remark that there are "are plenty of good ranked and accredited business schools in Africa." Actually, there are 6, if we're talking about EQUIS, Association of MBAs and AACSB - the ones that matter internationally. Is that "plenty" for Africa's billion + people?
quote
ralph

I think you're right. The main problem is that there are not plenty of good schools there - and complaining about there not being a model isn't going to help anybody.

I'd think that having globally accredited schools (even if they were "western" schools), on the continent would be a good thing. They'll provide the initial structure for future business leaders - many of whom would probably have left and gone to Europe or Asia for their MBAs because that used to be the only option. And, as the programs develop, they'll be forced to adapt their curriculum to better suit the needs of local needs. That's what has been happening in other "developing regions" like South America and the Middle East - and I'd assume it would happen eventually in Africa.

I think you're right. The main problem is that there are not plenty of good schools there - and complaining about there not being a model isn't going to help anybody.

I'd think that having globally accredited schools (even if they were "western" schools), on the continent would be a good thing. They'll provide the initial structure for future business leaders - many of whom would probably have left and gone to Europe or Asia for their MBAs because that used to be the only option. And, as the programs develop, they'll be forced to adapt their curriculum to better suit the needs of local needs. That's what has been happening in other "developing regions" like South America and the Middle East - and I'd assume it would happen eventually in Africa.
quote

Reply to Post

Related Business Schools

Durham, North Carolina 52 Followers 103 Discussions
Cape Town, South Africa 30 Followers 32 Discussions
Reading, United Kingdom 21 Followers 207 Discussions
Shanghai, China 38 Followers 78 Discussions
Beijing, China 6 Followers 102 Discussions

Other Related Content

Jan 11, 2024

LinkedIn Launches MBA Rankings of US Business Schools

News Jan 11, 2024

Hot Discussions